Duke News and Communications ___
Search Duke News
 
___
___ ___ ___ ___

 

Duke and Men's Lacrosse >> Background on New University Committees

EDITOR'S NOTE: On April 5, 2006, Duke University President Richard H. Brodhead announced in a letter to the Duke community that he would ask separate committees to report on issues raised in the wake of the controversy involving members of the men's lacrosse team. This fact sheet provides an update and additional information about the committees.

Summary of Committee Reports Completed to Date

The following groups and committees carried out reviews of issues raised by the lacrosse team incident:

Presidential Council

Chairs:
Roy Bostock (co-chair) runs his own investment firm, Sealedge Investments, LLC, of Greenwich, Conn. He also is chairman of the Partnership for a Drug-Free America, based in New York City. The partnership oversees the development of advertising and communications programs to encourage teens to lead healthy, drug-free lives. He serves as a director at Morgan Stanley, Northwest Airlines and Yahoo! A 1962 Duke graduate, Bostock served as a Duke trustee from 1990 to 2002 and as chair of the trustees' Business and Finance Committee. He was also a member of the trustees' Executive Committee and a director of the Duke University Health System from 1994 to 2002.

Wilhelmina Reuben-Cooke, (co-chair), one of the first three black students admitted to Duke's Woman's College, is provost/vice president academic affairs at the University of the District of Columbia. After graduating from Duke in 1967, she attended Harvard University as a Woodrow Wilson Scholar and in 1973 received a law degree from the University of Michigan as a John Hay Whitney Fellow. Reuben-Cooke was elected as a Duke trustee in 1989, becoming the first woman of color to serve in that capacity. She served on the board until 2001. Reuben-Cooke chaired the trustees' Academic Affairs Committee and served on the Executive Committee.

Roy Bostock
Roy Bostock
click here for hi-res image
  Wilhelmina Reuben-Cooke
Wilhelmina Reuben-Cooke
click here for hi-res image

Other committee members:


Sarah Dodds-Brown
Sarah Dodds-Brown,
bio
  Caroline Haynes
Julian Harris, bio
  William LeFew
Kathryn (Katie) Laidlaw, bio
 
Jesse Longoria
Morton Schapiro, bio
  Jackie Looney
Adam Silver, bio
  Marjorie McElroy
Shirley Tilghman, bio
 
Ben Ward
Judy Woodruff, bio
  Ben Ward
Phail Wynn, bio


Sarah Dodds-Brown serves as counsel for the Global Network and Establishment Services business units of American Express. Prior to that, she was an associate at the New York law firm of Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton and Garrison LLP. She has been outspoken about the challenges minority lawyers face in the field and pioneered the mentor program for minority lawyers at Paul, Weiss. A 1995 Duke graduate, she served on the Trinity College Board of Visitors from 1998 to 2005 and currently serves on the Financial Aid Initiative Committee. The Duke Student Government elected Dodds-Brown as the young trustee in 1995, and she served in that capacity from 1995-98.

Julian Harris, who was a Truman Scholar and a Rhodes Scholar, is a medical student at the University of Pennsylvania. He graduated summa cum laude from Duke with a bachelor's degree in health policy and medical ethics in 2000. An Angier B. Duke Scholar, he chaired the Honor Council and served as a student director on the board of the Center for Academic Integrity. After graduation, he earned a master's degree in economic and social history from Oxford University. He then joined the World Bank, where his work focused on strengthening national AIDS policy in several African countries. Harris currently serves on the advisory board of the Kenan Institute for Ethics.

Kathryn (Katie) Laidlaw is a senior associate with The Parthenon Group, a strategic advisory and investment firm, in Boston. She is also a member of Parthenon's Charitable Contributions Committee, serving as the community service coordinator. She graduated magna cum laude from Duke in 2004 with a bachelor's degree in French and European Studies, a minor in comparative area studies, and a certificate in Markets & Management. Laidlaw is serving a three-year elected term as a Duke young trustee and is a member of the Student Affairs Committee. She also serves as executive director of Inspire, a volunteer organization that offers strategic thinking and results-driven analysis to schools and nonprofits in five cities.

Morton Schapiro became president of Williams College in 2000. Prior to that, he served in a variety of administrative and faculty positions at Williams and at the University of Southern California, where he was professor of economics, dean and vice president. Schapiro is among the nation's premier authorities on the economics of higher education, with particular expertise in the area of college financing and affordability, and on trends in educational costs and student aid. He earned a bachelor's degree from Hofstra University in 1975 and a doctorate from the University of Pennsylvania in 1979.

Adam Silver, a 1984 graduate of Duke, will become NBA deputy commissioner and chief operating officer on July 1. During 14 years with the NBA, Silver has served in a variety of roles, most recently as president and COO of NBA Entertainment. He received his law degree from the University of Chicago Law School in 1988. In 2003, CNN and Time Magazine named Silver one of 20 Global Business Influentials. He serves on the Library Advisory Board at Duke.

Shirley Tilghman is president of Princeton University. She is one of the founding members of the National Advisory Council of the Human Genome Project Initiative for the National Institutes of Health, and has been a national leader in promoting women in science. She received national attention for a report on “Trends in the Careers of Life Scientists” that was issued in 1998 by a committee she chaired for the National Research Council. In 2002, Tilghman was one of five winners of the L'Oréal-UNESCO For Women in Science Award, and the following year received the Lifetime Achievement Award from the Society of Developmental Biology. She earned her Ph.D. in biochemistry from Temple University in Philadelphia and her Honors B. Sc. in chemistry from Queen's University in Kingston, Ontario.

Judy Woodruff, an award-winning broadcast journalist, has been an anchor at CNN, a White House correspondent for NBC and Washington correspondent for PBS's MacNeil/Lehrer NewsHour. This year she returned to PBS and the Lehrer NewsHour as a special correspondent. A 1968 Duke political science graduate, she will teach a class this fall in Duke's DeWitt Wallace Center for Media and Democracy, part of the Sanford Institute of Public Policy. She has been active in the formation of the Duke's Baldwin Scholars Program for undergraduate women. Woodruff served as a university trustee from 1985-97. In 1994, she received an honorary degree from Duke and was the commencement speaker.

Phail Wynn, the first African-American community college president in North Carolina, was appointed president of Durham Technical Institute, now Durham Technical Community College, in 1980. He is a member of the board of directors of the Triangle Community Foundation, founding member of the Greater Triangle Regional Council and member of the Board of Governors of Research Triangle Institute. He also sits on the corporate board of directors of SunTrust Bank and on the board of directors of UNC Health Care System. He is a past chair of the Greater Durham Chamber of Commerce. Prior to becoming president of Durham Tech, Wynn served with the 82nd Airborne Division and the U.S. Army Special Forces. He holds a bachelor of science degree from the University of Oklahoma, a master's degree in educational psychology, a doctorate from N.C. State University and a Master of Business Administration from the Kenan-Flagler School of Business at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

Purpose: Scrutinize Duke's responses to the lacrosse team incident, advise the president on best practices in other university settings and consider ways Duke can promote its values.

Timeline: Report to President Brodhead and the Duke Board of Trustees. First meeting this spring.

Back to top.

 

Investigation of Duke Administration Response

May 8, 2006 Report (PDF)

Chairs:
Julius Chambers, a veteran civil rights attorney, served as chancellor of North Carolina Central University from 1993 to 2001. As an attorney in Charlotte, he successfully litigated landmark U.S. Supreme Court cases concerning school busing and desegregation, voting rights and legislative redistricting and Title VII employment discrimination. Prior to becoming chancellor at his alma mater, he served as the director-counsel of the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund from 1984 to 1992.

William G. Bowen is president of The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation. He was president of Princeton University from 1972-1988, where he also was professor of economics and public affairs. Bowen is the author or co-author of 20 books, including "Equity and Excellence in American Higher Education," with Martin A. Kurzweil and Eugene M. Tobin; "Reclaiming the Game: College Sports and Educational Values" with Sarah A. Levin; "The Game of Life: College Sports and Educational Values" with James Shulman; and the Grawemeyer Award-winning "The Shape of the River: Long-Term Consequences of Considering Race in College and University Admissions" with Derek Bok.

Julius Chambers
Julius Chambers
click here for hi-res image
  William Bowen
William Bowen
click here for hi-res image

Other committee members: None

Purpose: Investigate the Duke administration's performance in responding to the allegations involving the Duke men's lacrosse team. Specifically, address the perception that the university did not respond as quickly as it should have and point to lessons the episode can teach.

Timeline: Report to President Brodhead and the Duke University Board of Trustees by May 15.

Back to top.

 

Investigation of Men's Lacrosse

May 1, 2006 Report

Chair:
James E. Coleman Jr. joined the Duke Law School faculty in 1996. A 1970 Harvard University graduate who received his law degree from Columbia University in 1974, he worked for 16 years in private practice in New York and Washington, D.C. He investigated two members of Congress in 1978 as chief counsel for the U.S. House of Representatives' Committee on Standards of Official Conduct. At Duke, Coleman has previously headed a committee that reviewed and recommended changes to the university's policy regarding drug use by athletes, leading to the implementation of stringent penalties for the use of steroids, blood doping and masking agents.

James Coleman
James Coleman
click here for hi-res image
 

Committee members:

Gary Gereffi
Gary Gereffi,
professor, sociology
  Kerry Haynie
Kerry Haynie,
associate professor,
political science
  Prasad Kasibhatla
Prasad Kasibhatla, associate professor, Nicholas School of the Environment & Earth Sciences
 
Tod Laursen
Tod Laursen,
professor, Pratt School of Engineering
  Martha Putallaz
Martha Putallaz,
professor, psychology; executive director, Duke University Talent Identification Program
  photo not available
Annabel Wharton, professor, art and art history
 

Purpose: Lead Duke's examination of the on- and off-campus conduct of its men's lacrosse team. The panel, a subcommittee of the university's Athletic Council, will not look into the criminal allegations against the team; rather, it will investigate "the extent to which the cumulative behavior of many over a number of years signifies a deeper problem for which significant corrective actions are called for."

Timeline: Report to President Brodhead and the Executive Committee of the Academic Council, the university's faculty senate, by May 1.

Back to top.

 

Examination of Student Judicial Process and Practices

May 1, 2006 Report

Chair:
Prasad Kasibhatla, who received his master's and doctoral degrees from the University of Kentucky, is an associate professor of environmental chemistry in Duke's Nicholas School of the Environment and Earth Sciences. He has served on a number of university committees, including the group that recently overhauled Duke's policy for student-athletes who test positive for steroids and other performance-enhancing drugs. He also is chair of the steering committee on Duke's strategic plan update.

Prasad Kasibhatla
Prasad Kasibhatla
click here for hi-res image
 

Committee members:

photo not available
Aura Gimm,
assistant professor, biomedical engineering
  Caroline Haynes
Caroline Haynes,
assistant clinical
professor, psychiatry
  William LeFew
Jackie Looney,
associate dean for
graduate student affairs, Graduate School
 
Jesse Longoria
Rachel Lovingood,
graduate student
  Jackie Looney
Marjorie McElroy, professor, economics
  Marjorie McElroy
Ben Ward,
associate dean
for student development, associate professor, philosophy
 
Ben Ward
Gary Ybarra,
associate professor, electrical & computer engineering
   

Purpose: The Academic Council's Student Affairs Committee will examine the way Duke deals with problems of student behavior by reviewing the existing judicial system for students and making recommendations for change. The committee will look at several questions, such as whether the Community Standard and policies that apply to student behavior adequately convey Duke's values and behavioral expectations; "whether distinctions between on-campus and off-campus behaviors, and Duke's approach to adjudication of those behaviors, are appropriate; and whether there are limitations in the policies that prevent various behaviors from being addressed appropriately and effectively.

Timeline: Report to President Brodhead, Academic Council chair Paul Haagen and the Executive Committee of the Academic Council, the university's faculty senate, by May 1.

Back to top.

 

Campus Culture Initiative

Read the release and the February 26, 2007 report

Chair:
Robert Thompson, vice provost for undergraduate education and dean of Trinity College, joined the Duke faculty in 1975 and holds appointments in the Department of Psychology: Social and Health Sciences, the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, and the Department of Pediatrics. A graduate of LaSalle College and the University of North Dakota, he previously served on the faculty of Georgetown University Medical Center and Catholic University of America. At Duke, he has been heavily involved with undergraduate education, becoming dean of undergraduate affairs, Trinity College, Arts and Sciences, and then dean of Trinity College in 1999. He was named vice provost for undergraduate education in 2004.

Vice-Chair:
Larry Moneta is vice president for student affairs at Duke, where he leads the central planning and policy formation concerning student issues. Moneta worked in student affairs on a variety of campuses before joining the Duke community in August 2001, most recently at the University of Pennsylvania as associate vice president for campus services from 1997 to 2001 and associate vice provost for university life from 1992 to 1997. He received his Ed.D. and B.S. from the University of Massachusetts and his M.Ed. from Springfield College. In addition to his administrative duties, Moneta teaches a wide variety of courses, consults for institutions across the country, and presents regularly at conferences and workshops.

Robert Thompson
Robert Thompson
click here for hi-res image
  Larry Moneta
Larry Moneta
click here for hi-res image

Committee Members:

Faculty:
Anne Allison, chair and professor, Department of Cultural Anthropology
Philip Cook, professor, Sanford Institute of Public Policy
Robert Cook-Deegan, director, IGSP Center for Genome Ethics, Law and Policy
Jeffrey Forbes, assistant professor of the practice, Department of Computer Science
Karla Holloway, professor, Department of English
Noah Pickus, associate director, Kenan Institute for Ethics
Marie Lynn Miranda, associate research professor, Nicholas School of the Environment
Barry Myers, professor, Department of Biomedical Engineering
Suzanne Shanahan, assistant professor, Department of Sociology
Peter Wood, professor, Department of History

Administrators:
Zoila Airall, assistant vice president for student affairs
Steve Nowicki, dean of the natural sciences
Ben Reese, vice president of institutional equity
Jackie Silar, associate athletics director
Sam Wells, dean of the chapel

Students:
Trisha Bailey ('07)
Melissa Mang ('09)
Chauncey Nartey ('07)
Audrey Ellerbee (G '09)
Iman Washington ('07)
Elliott Wolf ('08)

Alumni:
Charlotte Clark, Trinity College '79, MEM '83 (Durham, NC)
J. Derek Penn, Trinity College '79, B'84 (New York, New York)

Purpose: A rigorous self-examination "to evaluate and suggest improvements in the ways Duke educates students in the values of personal responsibility, consideration for others and mutual respect in the face of difference and disagreement."

Charge

  • Write a statement of the values and behaviors that should guide Duke students in their relations with others;
  • Evaluate and suggest improvements in the ways students develop personal responsibility, social responsibility, and civic engagement;
  • Assess how students relate to each other and other members of the campus and community across bounds of race, gender and other social divisions;
  • Assess the extent to which Duke institutional practices promote values and behaviors expected of students;
  • Assess the role that faculty play in the development of student values and behavior and make recommendations for increasing interaction between students and faculty in campus life; and
  • Recommend initiatives to promote a more responsible approach to the culture of campus drinking.

Timeline: Issue a preliminary report to President Brodhead by December 1, with a follow-up report in May 2007.

Back to top.

 

 
___ ___ ___ ___ ___
  © 2006 Office of News & Communications
615 Chapel Drive, Box 90563, Durham, NC 27708-0563
(919) 684-2823
Send questions or comments about this web site to webmaster.