Skip to main content

Pope's Visit to Turkey Seeks to Unify Faith and Reason, Not Pursue Dialogue with Islam, Duke Professor Says

Pope sees Greek philosophy linking Catholicism and Orthodoxy in contrast to Islam and Protestantism, G¼ven G¼zeldere says

Pope Benedict XVI's trip to Istanbul is not primarily about making a diplomatic gesture toward Turkey or Islam, but a philosophical and political move to embrace the faith and reason he sees shared by Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy, says a Duke University professor.

"This pope is an academic pope," said Güven Güzeldere, a professor of philosophy at Duke who is from Turkey. "He is not so much focused on the politics of the day or a dialogue between Islam and Christianity as positioning Catholicism in alliance with Orthodoxy."

Güzeldere teaches a summer study abroad course in Istanbul called "Thinking about God: The Nature of Religious Belief at the Crossroads of Judaism, Christianity and Islam." He will travel on Thursday to Turkey to give a talk on the intersection of philosophy and brain science.

"In the pope's mind, the European and Christian identity has been shaped in a very fundamental way by the rational philosophical inquiry that was developed in ancient Greece," Güzeldere said. "By visiting Patriarch Bartholomew I [the head of the Orthodox churches], the pope wants to recover some of the rational roots of faith he believes are preserved in Orthodox Christianity."

Güzeldere said the pope's visit is also a political move that would bring together Orthodoxy and Catholicism and situate them against Protestantism.

"The pope thinks this is particularly important in this day and age because he thinks Protestantism took the rational essence out of Christianity and set up the modern contrasts of science versus religion and faith versus reason," Güzeldere said.

"He also wants to situate this Greco-Roman Christian concept of God who acts according to reason against what he considers the Muslim concept of a transcendent God who is not bound by rationality."

Güzeldere said he has found the pope's reading of Islamic theology "surprisingly cursory, and given the deep theological disagreements between the Orthodox and Catholic treatment of issues such as the Immaculate Conception, purgatory and the professed infallibility of the pope, a profound allegiance of the two churches seems more like a bit of wishful thinking."